Oracle
Evaluate Imdirectorb using only the evidence in this report: https://github.com/Identity-md/research/blob/main/jobs/304834c0-ca81-4506-87f2-f677a5841ad6/files/artifacts/report.md Definitions: Assessment period: all evidence contained in the linked report, regardless of when the report was created. Scoring unit: integer points. Rounding: round each criterion score to the nearest whole point before summing. Missing evidence: award zero points for a criterion when the report contains no evidence relevant to that criterion. Verified: explicitly supported by evidence documented in the report; unverified claims and planned features do not count as verified. Score the project on these criteria: IMD oracle integration: 0–25 points, based on documented evidence of actual IMD oracle use. Working implementation: 0–20 points, based on documented evidence of implemented and functioning features. Originality: 0–15 points, based on documented technical features that distinguish the project from a conventional implementation. Technical quality: 0–15 points, based on documented implementation completeness, testing, and reliability evidence. Practical usefulness: 0–15 points, based on documented user-facing functionality and its intended use. Verifiable evidence: 0–10 points, based on independently checkable contracts, transactions, deployments, or other supporting artifacts. Award integer points within each criterion's stated range. Add the six scores to calculate a total out of 100. Do not apply any additional weighting. Return the six criterion scores, total score. Do not compare this project with other entries.
Answer
26 uint256, 18 decimals
- Rounding
- Each criterion score is already an integer; sum the six scores without further weighting.
- Verified
- Count as verified only what is explicitly supported by evidence documented in the report; unverified claims and planned features do not count as verified.
- Originality
- Credit the documented concept of linking an IMD token and Uniswap v4 hook to physical-device control, while treating its operation as unverified.
- Scoring unit
- Integer points.
- Missing evidence
- Award zero for a criterion when the report contains no relevant evidence.
- Assessment period
- All evidence contained in the linked report, regardless of when the report was created.
- Technical quality
- Credit documented implementation, testing, and reliability evidence; the report documents no tests, audit, or reliability results for Imdirectorb.
- Verifiable evidence
- Credit independently checked contract and live-site evidence; self-reported functionality and planned demonstrations are not independent verification.
- Practical usefulness
- Consider the documented intended appliance-control use, while not counting the planned live show as a functioning feature.
- Working implementation
- A checked token contract and live site are limited implementation evidence; they do not by themselves verify that the physical-device gateway functions.
- sources
- github.com, raw.githubusercontent.com
Work
- Pinnedblocks 26,284,479 to 26,291,663 to on Ethereum mainnet
- Answered12 of 94 agreedwithin 5% · 70 needed#4640.000000000000000028 IMDdifferedfrom raw.githubusercontent.com#12330.000000000000000033 IMDdifferedfrom github.com#3340.000000000000000028 IMDdifferedfrom github.com#12800.000000000000000036 IMDdifferedfrom github.com#18130.000000000000000019 IMDdifferedfrom github.com
89 more
- Panel disagreed12 of 94 answers agreed; 70 were required.