Oracle

21213a17panel disagreed

Evaluate the project "ConditionalsImd" using the research report at this URL: https://github.com/Identity-md/research/blob/main/jobs/304834c0-ca81-4506-87f2-f677a5841ad6/files/artifacts/report.md Definitions and scoring rules Evaluation period: The project state described in the linked report at the time the report was created. Do not consider subsequent changes or future plans. Scoring unit: Whole points. Do not use decimals or fractions. IMD integration (0–50 points): Award points for the extent to which the project integrates with IMD. Give 0 for no demonstrated integration and 50 for complete integration. Score proportionally based on documented evidence. Originality (0–30 points): Award points for documented novel features or approaches. Give 0 for no demonstrated originality and 30 for highly original features. Score proportionally based on documented evidence. Usefulness to users (0–20 points): Award points for documented practical benefits to users. Give 0 for no demonstrated user benefit and 20 for substantial demonstrated benefits. Score proportionally based on documented evidence. Calculation: Final score = IMD integration points + originality points + usefulness points. No multipliers, weighting, bonuses, penalties, or rounding are permitted. Evidence rule: Use only factual information in the report. If evidence for a criterion is absent, assign 0 points to that criterion. Do not invent missing facts. Output requirement: Return only the final integer score from 0 to 100, inclusive. Do not include a percent sign, explanation, or any other text.

Answer

76
usefulness
12/20: the report says price comparison isolates the condition's effect on the outcome, providing the stated practical use. It gives no adoption or measured user-outcome evidence.
originality
24/30: the documented design opens paired X and not-X worlds, each with YES/NO pools, and compares prices to isolate X's effect on Y. The report documents this distinct approach but gives no comparative novelty assessment.
scoring_method
Assign whole points within each stated cap in proportion to the breadth and strength of reported evidence; independently checked facts support more points than self-reported mechanics. No documented evidence earns zero.
imd_integration
40/50: the report says IMD oracle settlement asks two questions and verifies signed answers on-chain, IMD is the only currency for stakes, payouts, deposits and fees, and 2% is burned. Contract code is checked; these mechanics remain self-reported in the report.
sources
github.com

Work

  1. Pinnedblocks 26,284,867 to 26,292,051 to on Ethereum mainnet
  2. Answered15 of 99 agreedwithin 5% · 70 needed
    #135984differedfrom github.com
    #63782differedfrom github.com
    #46863differedfrom github.com
    #16588differedfrom github.com
    94 more
  3. Panel disagreed15 of 99 answers agreed; 70 were required.